Pick Your Poison

The absolute filthiest version of Would You Rather ever made. Torture each other by creating the toughest choices.

See details below.

Reservation INFO

  • Only one reservation per party per night.
  • Maximum reservation time is 2.5 hours, except for private rooms and specific nights.

THE DETAILS

Everything good comes at a cost. What are you willing to live with? Win by playing your best perk and poisoning your neighbors.

Each round of play starts by choosing a judge. The remaining players will play a perk face-down(a white card that contains “good stuff”) that they think the judge will like. After every player plays a perk, the players continue to play poisons face-down (a green card that conversely contains “bad stuff”) on their neighbor’s perks.

After everyone has played their cards, it’s time for the judge to read all the choices aloud and pick his poison! The winning perk gets a point and play continues by rotating the role of the judge.

Players

3 Players, 4 Players, 5 Players, 6 Players, 7 Players, 8 Players

Game Length

Complexity

Middleweight

Mechanics

Humor, NSFW, Party Game

Purchase for Your Home

Support Vigilante by buying here: https://amzn.to/3nCgjSt

Reservation FAQs

Is Vigilante Kid Friendly?

Vigilante is a cocktail bar environment: we are not designed with kids in mind. All minors must be accompanied by an adult. We are 21+ after 10pm.

Can we make a reservation for more than 2.5 hours?

To ensure everyone gets to game, we limit table stays to 2.5 hours. If no party needs the table after your reservation we are happy to extend your stay at no cost. This happens frequently on weekdays. To book an extra long reservation, click here.

Do you allow outside food and beverage?

We do not allow any outside food and beverages, except for cakes/desserts for celebrating major life events. If you do bring such an item, please note we do not provide cutlery or plates. In accordance with health code, we may not store these items either.

How do I make a reservation for more than 8 people?

We have space for large parties. Please email hello(at)vigilantebar.com for assistance!